Not sure where this will go but after subscribing I never received the PS badge. I subscribed on July 1st.
Since then how many matches have you registered for online and how many have completed and posted results?
6 matches so far since I signed up and completed.
Here are two of them. A hosemaster match and a steel challenge match.
So it all depends on the match was created, and when you signed up for it based on when your icon was created. Looks to be working properly.
Thank you for getting this to work.